The Key Word.
Posted in SoForth on April 30th, 2006On May 1, tomorrow, the business of running the US will be disrupted. According to CNN, “Meatpacking plants will shut down. Markets won’t open. Trucks won’t roll. Students will walk out of school. Millions of people will take to America’s streets in possibly unprecedented numbers.”
Further, “Boycott organizers are demanding amnesty and the chance for the estimated 11 million to 12 million illegal immigrants in the United States to earn citizenship.”
Amnesty. For people who break the law. Because that makes sense.
I don’t have a damn thing against people who want to leave home and find a better life elsewhere. More than that, it takes an enormous amount of time, energy, and red tape to get into the US legally. However, I can’t abide by people who break our laws to get here and then complain because there’s a possibility they’ll get caught and deported.
Besides, not investing in the long term is just lazy. Yesterday on NPR I heard a story of an immigrant from Sudan who escaped desperate conditions is his own country by getting himself and his family to Britain. There, they all waited for one year - a full year - to get everything in order to emigrate to the US. I’m sure that year wasn’t easy; it was probably filled with phone calls and living in refugee conditions and paperwork and working hard to know, for sure, that once they arrived in the US, it would be permanent.
Don’t tell me people from anywhere else in the world can’t do the same. Their life may have been one of poverty and lack of opportunity, but I’ll wager it was nothing compared to what’s going on in Darfur. If the Sudanese can a way, anyone can.
But fine, you don’t want to invest in your future. You’d rather walk or swim across the US border and remain ILLEGAL. Great. But listen to yourselves and your supporters:
The great slogan of the American Revolution was ‘No Taxation Without Representation … Millions of human beings today and for many years are being taxed, and they have absolutely no representation. In fact, they are being bashed every day and humiliated. (quote from the CNN article linked above)
You’re paying taxes to a country in which you do not legally belong. You could skip it, you know. Uncle Sam would not be the wiser, unlike during the American Revolution when King George and company knew who was here and what they owed. That’s because the colonists were legal immigrants.
Rosa Parks steered a new course for history against racism and for workers rights … This right here is today’s Montgomery bus boycott. (full quote may be found here)
Rosa Parks was a hero fighting for every US citizen’s rights. ILLEGAL immigrants want to get something they don’t deserve because they (foolishly) pay taxes into a system while breaking that very system’s laws.
Referring to the estimated 12 million undocumented immigrants in the United States … the immigrants today “share the same history of slavery.” (same link as above)
The very definition of slavery is not having a choice. Slaves are forced into their situation without recourse or freedom to make any other decision. Immigrants have the choice to come here legally and under no duress whatsoever. It’s insulting, in fact, to even compare the two - as if the Rosa Parks comparison wasn’t bad enough.
If immigrants continue demonstrating in large numbers, are they going to fire all of them? (quote from this article in the Chicago Sun Times)
Well, yes. People get fired for lesser things every day. More than that, if you are an ILLEGAL immigrant, you have NO right to work in the first place. Don’t be surprised if you attend the boycott and/or rallies and do not have a job to go back to on Tuesday. I’d fire you.
We have to demonstrate that we came here to succeed … There are different ways to show we love the United States. We just have to make sure we don’t damage anyone. (same article as above)
You could show how much you love this country by getting everyone’s citizenship in order, or by flying only US flags at your rallies. And damage how? Like, I don’t know, leaving work or school and gumming up traffic, all to make a statement about people who break US law? Can you even hear yourself?
My favorite quotes, however, are from the children of ILLEGAL immigrants who were born here. “Well, my dad has been working here and paying taxes for 30 years.” Yes, he has. ILLEGALLY. And where was he when President Reagan granted amnesty to all ILLEGAL immigrants back in 1986? That was 20 years ago. Your dad could have made himself legal just 10 years after getting here. He could have saved himself, but he didn’t. Dad is breaking the law. Period.
This argument is not against immigration. It is against ILLEGAL immigration. If you are unclear of the difference, maybe you should read the definition of the key word in this debate.
Careful, you may have to remove your rose-colored glasses to understand it.
If ignorance of the law is no excuse, then knowing the law and still breaking it is truly criminal.
